Civil Antitrust 2026, Part 3: How to Prepare, and How to Avoid Becoming the Next Case

Parts 1 and 2 described the enforcement posture and the theories. This final part is the preparation list. The goal is to reduce three exposures at once: government civil enforcement, criminal exposure, and private lawsuits that follow either of them. These steps are practical judgments from the trends described, not legal advice for any particular company.
Start with a Map, Not a Policy
Most antitrust programs begin with a policy and training. A better start is a map of where the company actually touches competitors, competitor data, and market power:
- Pricing, revenue-management, bidding, and procurement tools, with the data each one ingests and where its outputs go.
- Benchmarking, surveys, industry data services, and trade association programs.
- Contract terms with customers, suppliers, distributors, payers, and platforms that restrict dealing with rivals.
- Rebate, discount, and loyalty programs, and whether they vary between large and small customers.
- Hiring, compensation benchmarking, and no-poach or non-solicit terms.
- Collaborations, joint ventures, standard-setting, and safety consortia, including those in AI.
- Pending and planned transactions.
This inventory is the baseline for everything else, and it is what the Division’s compliance evaluation questions on AI and algorithmic tools effectively ask for.
Ten Risk-Reduction Priorities

- Pricing tools and data. Ask whether any tool pools nonpublic competitor data or feeds your data to others. The theory in the Third Circuit and in the RealPage decrees turns on current, nonpublic, granular data, mutual awareness, and high adherence to recommendations. Where a tool uses such data, limit recency and granularity, aggregate, and document the review. Do not treat an override right as a defense: if recommendations are almost always followed, the adherence will be used against you.
- Benchmarks and information exchanges. Review every recurring exchange of data with competitors, including through a trade association or consultant. Prefer historical, aggregated, anonymized data, handled by a third party under written guardrails, and avoid forward-looking price and capacity information.
- Contract terms. Review exclusivity, loyalty rebates tied to share-of-requirements, anti-steering, tiering, most-favored-nation, and all-or-nothing terms. The Corteva and OhioHealth resolutions show that these terms are now enforcement targets.
- Discounts and price differences. If you sell to both chains and independents, confirm that price differences are justified by cost or competition. The Robinson-Patman revival, though narrow so far, is real.
- Labor-market practices. Eliminate wage-fixing, information sharing on compensation among competitors, and no-poach arrangements unless they are narrow and ancillary to a legitimate transaction.
- AI and industry collaborations. Put antitrust counsel in the room for safety, pacing, standards, and data-sharing discussions. Write down the procompetitive purpose, limit the information exchanged, and keep agendas and minutes.
- Deal planning. Identify competitive overlaps early, prepare remedy options and divestiture candidates, and expect the Division to discuss fixes sooner. Prepare for state interest in large or local-impact deals, since states may act after a federal clearance. Track new premerger copy requirements (California’s SB 25 for filings starting in 2027).
- Document discipline. Greco’s example of executives whose story was contradicted by their own documents applies to every investigation and lawsuit. Train employees to describe business purposes accurately and without exaggeration, and avoid language such as “dominate,” “lock up,” or “keep prices disciplined.” Ordinary-course documents must match the narrative you will present.
- Detection and speed. Build an internal reporting channel, a protocol for escalating competitor contacts, and a decision path for leniency or self-reporting. With whistleblower rewards and leniency both rewarding speed, a company that waits to investigate may lose first position.
- Individual accountability. The Division charges people. Training should reach salespeople, pricing analysts, engineers, procurement staff, and executives, with consequences for violations.
Specific Steps to Avoid Private Antitrust Suits
Private plaintiffs follow government action, and they also pick up cases from news reports of pricing patterns. To lower the risk and the cost:

- Avoid being the next “follow-on.” If a competitor, vendor, or trade association in your industry is under investigation, assess your exposure immediately and issue a preservation notice. Private class actions often start within days of a public announcement.
- Prepare for the pleading stage. The Third Circuit’s analysis shows courts looking for plausible allegations about nonpublic data exchange, mutual awareness, and adherence to recommendations. Facts on those points are your best motion-to-dismiss record, so know them in advance.
- Control the vendor relationship. Obtain from software and data vendors written descriptions of what data they collect, how it is used, and whether it is shared. Include antitrust compliance representations, audit rights, and data-use limits in contracts, and reconsider vendors that cannot explain how their model uses competitors’ data.
- Consider the injury and causation defenses. Courts still require antitrust injury. A consumer class action over Google’s search defaults was dismissed for lack of evidence of what better options would have existed. Understand your market well enough to challenge causation and damages.
- Plan insurance and indemnity. Review D&O and other coverage for antitrust claims, and consider indemnities from vendors and trade associations.
Cooperating with Government Inquiries
The Division says it will not treat investigations as a tax if they are reasonably scoped, and it rewards candor. If a civil investigative demand or subpoena arrives: involve counsel immediately, issue a legal hold, understand whether the matter could be criminal, and coordinate responses across federal and state authorities, since cooperation with one can affect exposure to others. Prompt, accurate, and well-organized responses, along with early remedy ideas where appropriate, are usually the best route to a negotiated outcome.
Governance
Boards should ask for a periodic antitrust risk report that covers the map above, major pricing and contract programs, pending transactions, hotline reports, and any government contacts. Management should be able to show that antitrust review is part of AI and pricing-tool deployments, not an afterthought. An AI governance program that never asks the antitrust question, as Glad put it, is not enough.
The Bottom Line
Enforcers have signaled that they will settle when companies bring credible solutions, litigate when they do not, and rely on whistleblowers, states, and private plaintiffs to extend the reach of their theories. Companies that map their exposure, fix the high-risk mechanisms, keep their documents honest, and move fast on red flags are the ones that avoid becoming the case study.











